Museums: Missions and Acquisitions (M2A) Project
A first-of-its-kind national study of institutional collecting practices and policies that aims to inform an evidence-based framework for the future collecting decisions of U.S. museums.
U.S. museums find themselves at an inflection point where they are grappling with the provenance of objects that came into their collections, sometimes as the result of armed conflict, theft, and looting, while the illegal trafficking of cultural objects and ongoing conflicts continue to place cultural heritage at increasing risk every day. More than ever, museums are being held accountable by their communities to maintain high ethical standards in their acquisition, stewardship, and deaccessioning of cultural objects.
Despite significant debate and discussion about the treatment of cultural property in American museums, the field lacks comprehensive data to guide institutional decision-making around several key issues: 1) What constitutes an ethical acquisition; 2) whether continuing to collect is necessary; and 3) what to do when their legal or ethical title to their collections comes under question.
The M2A Project seeks to inform solutions to these challenges by identifying how museums are acquiring objects today and how collecting fits within the broader social purpose of museums now and in the future.
- A three-year research project funded by the Institute of Museum and Library Services (IMLS), the M2A Project is documenting collecting practices within American museums that have historically held cultural objects—including fine art, archaeological, and ethnographic collections—with a focus on the lifecycle of collections, from acquisition to deaccessioning, as well as the relationship between museums’ collecting practices and missions. The project is developing data that have never before been brought together on this scale and made available to museum leaders and policymakers.
- The M2A Project grows out of the PennCHC’s work on the Cultural Property Experts On Call (CPEOC) Program. Established under a memorandum of understanding with the U.S. Department of State’s Cultural Heritage Coordinating Committee, the CPEOC Program assists U.S. law enforcement agents in identifying cultural objects in federal investigations. Since 2020, the PennCHC has collaborated with experts from more than 100 museums and universities to identify and collect data on cultural property. The M2A Project builds on this momentum to address questions of collecting, object ownership, and provenance in the context of U.S. museums.
- The PennCHC’s Director of Research and Programs, Brian I. Daniels, serves as the principal investigator and Executive Director, Richard M. Leventhal, serves as co-principal investigator of the M2A Project. The PennCHC’s Administrative Coordinator, Corinne Muller, and Research Coordinator, Kayla Kane, are also part of the core project team.
- The M2A Project includes Research Analysts Soleil Hawley, Daniela Tanico, and Alyssa Thiel, as well as undergraduate and graduate student researchers from the University of Pennsylvania and beyond.
- The M2A Project is designed and implemented by the PennCHC staff who operate the Cultural Property Experts On Call (CPEOC) Program. For four years, the CPEOC Program has been working at the intersection of law enforcement, academia, and museums to track data on cultural property imports as they are being detained by law enforcement and to engage the expertise of subject matter experts attuned to the ethics of acquiring imported collections.
By 2027, the PennCHC will share the M2A Project’s findings through a state-of-the-field report that synthesizes current collecting practices and spotlights innovative case studies across the U.S. museum sector. The report will be freely available online and shared directly with stakeholders in the museum sector, government agencies, and grantmaking organizations.
- Across the country, many museum practitioners and stakeholders are looking to rethink collecting practices and identify models that reshape the social purpose of museums and their collections. The findings shared in the M2A Project’s state-of-the-field report will help museum staff at all levels of the profession, cultural leaders, trustees, grantmakers, and policymakers champion higher collecting standards and strengthen museum services for the American public.
- The state-of-the-field report will also educate the American public on the role of museums as stewards of cultural heritage and the actions they can take to maintain public trust in their collecting practices.
This project was made possible in part by the Institute of Museum and Library Services (IMLS) (MG-255529-OMS-24). To learn more about IMLS, visit www.imls.gov.